Homes in Black and Latino neighborhoods still undervalued 50 years after US banned using race in real estate appraisals
By The Conversation Contributions
The big idea
Our
new research on home appraisals shows neighborhood racial composition still drives unequal home values, despite laws that forbid real estate professionals from explicitly using race when evaluating a property’s worth. Published in the journal
Social Problems, our study finds this growing inequality results from both historical policies and contemporary practices.
In the 1930s, the federal government institutionalized a process for evaluating how much a property was worth.
Often called redlining, this process used neighborhood racial and socioeconomic composition to determine home values. Homes in white communities were deemed more valuable than identical dwellings in communities of color.
Redlining has been illegal for 43 years – but it is still depressing the value of Black and Latino neighborhoods.
Legislative action in the late 1960s and 1970s prohibited this practice. But the law allowed appraisers to
use past sale prices to determine home values. Our research shows how using old, race-based sale prices ensured appraisers continued to define homes in white neighborhoods as worth more than similar homes in Black and Latino communities. Racism was baked into the system.
Real estate professionals compound these historical inequalities by assuming communities of color
are undesirable, even when real estate demand suggests otherwise.
Why it matters
For most U.S. families, their home is their greatest asset. As their home appreciates in value,
their wealth increases, enabling them to fund their retirement, their children’s college educations or unexpected expenses like large medical bills.
Families who have historically owned homes in white neighborhoods can afford these increased costs because their appreciating home values have expanded their relative wealth. But for everyone else, high housing costs are a burden. For many renters, high housing costs combined with stagnant wages have created an acute and worsening
affordable housing crisis. Many struggle to
remain housed – including during the pandemic – and very few can save enough to transition into home ownership.
What still isn’t known
Article Tags