Oscar, Masilibambe Lingatshoni!

By Luxolo September

Dear Oscar,

Pardon me for departing from the norm of addressing you either by your clan name ‘Diya’ or title “MEC” or for that matter ‘Sihlalo’. It is no sign of disrespect. In normal times, I would address you like that. But these are no ordinary times for the land of my forefathers. The Eastern Cape Province – which has stagnated and regressed over the years – needs clean oxygen and resuscitation.

A lot, I’m led to believe, rests on your shoulders. Unlike many, I will not fall into the trap of thinking you carry a magic stick that will wave all the problems of the Eastern Cape away – but in you, many see someone who can take the province out of the political and economic intensive care unit.

In addressing the Methodist church on the eve of the passing of our Isithwalandwe Nelson Mandela in 2013, former President Thabo Mbeki spoke at length about the quality of leadership required to take South Africa from what he earlier called “directionless and unguided national drift.”

Mbeki, in uncharacteristic animated demeanor and using his hands to illustrate either his exasperation or to drive a point, harped on the fact that South Africa had fallen short of the important task of grooming leaders that will respond to the challenges today and who, in turn, will be able to give guidance and create a better life for all.

What President Mbeki didn’t say was that – even if unwittingly – he had also contributed to the challenge we were facing because, while preoccupied with the York of governance, he took his eye off the project of developing leaders who will inspire and work.

Over a year ago, the Eastern Cape was swept-up in the euphoria of your elections. At last at the helm, we had a young person who, because of his perceived closeness to the ground, would stir the ship in another direction.

The late President, Nelson Mandela & former President, Thabo Mbeki

This optimism reached us who reside outside the borders of the province but whose umbilical cords are buried in the fertile land of ePhondweni.  By your election, many felt that there was a response to the question of ‘quality of leadership needed’ to respond to the challenges, however, you inherit many problems.

The healthcare system is in a mess (don’t believe the spin your department of health gives you – if you don’t believe me, just drive to Butterworth Hospital or Nqamakwe clinic and Cofimvaba Hospital and see for yourself). The education system is ailing (yes – there was backslapping in January over what many called an improvement, but we are second last).
You inherit a province whose economy in the rural areas is now 90% dependent on social grants. You inherit a province where the government is a primary employer (this should not be the case – we need a government that spends money on services and infrastructural projects not a public sector salary bill).

The Landscape of the Eastern Cape

You inherit a province that is falling far behind in attracting tourism.  The tourism industry in the Eastern Cape needs a new strategy – not just a document – but a new path that must be walked in order to find our place in the map of global competitiveness, however, you inherit a province that has disinvested in infrastructure.

At a recent event organised by the Black Management Forum – which Vuyani Jarana and I gate crashed – BMF President Andile Nomlala made some valuable points: 
He said: “We must invest in infrastructure or else we will continue with this unabated consumption.”

In sports, you will find a province which despite many brave efforts by administrators and amateur club owners, is home to failing sport organisations from rugby, cricket, football, to mention a few. If you do not believe me, visit the offices of the Border Bulldogs, or take a small drive to Border cricket and ask, besides Makhaya Ntini, Mfuneko Ngam, and Mark Boucher, when last, we produce a player that contributed to the success of the Proteas. The Southern Kings are now playing in front of empty stadium rejected by the people they are supposed to serve. I can go on and on. 

Sadly, for you, you also inherit a lot of people who will be telling you what you want to hear and not what you need to hear. However, we have trust that you will resist the seductive temptation to only have ‘yes-men’ and ‘yes-women’ within earshot.

The solutions for the Eastern Cape will largely come from the people of the Eastern Cape. We must reject this notion that we are not capable of coming up with solutions for our problems and our over-reliance in outsourcing intellectual property. 

You, Oscar, also inherit a passive black middle class – that has become complacent and to some degree complicit in our province’s mess. You find young people whose zeal is deflated by – at times – older people who block ideas and resist change. 

Back at the BMF gathering, I gatecrashed and heard Nomlala correctly add that: 

“We (professionals – and I suspect he was referring to black professionals) made a mistake in the past of making our leaders our gods. That [mistake] cannot be repeated. From today onwards, we will engage differently. We will no longer be engaging in uncritical relationships. The professionals in this province must criticize you when you are wrong.”

Nomlala has a point. We want you to succeed. It is in the interest of our generation and our young brothers and sisters, but we will not be "blinded by the gifts from the feasts" (borrowed from Mazizi Kunene) - to buy our silence.  We owe this to you.

There are no short-cuts for you, and these are not problems for you alone to sort but for us a collective to resolve. You cannot and will not be the “Big Man” of the Eastern Cape. However, at times, a generation produces people whom it anoints with the heavy task of changing the status quo. This small group of change agents – with whom we can include the likes of Robert Sobukwe, Chris Hani, Bantu Biko, Joe Slovo, Winnie Mandela, Griffith Mxenge, Mandela, Govan Mbeki, to mention a few – must either embrace the York or, to misquote Fanon, betray their mission. Of course, this is not to equate you with these heroes and heroines of our struggle but to rather drive a strong point of people who understood their task and fulfilled it. 

The Eastern Cape’s contribution to this country’s history is well documented. 

However, now what we have is the fading sun of hope that once shone brightly over our beautiful landscape.

 As sons of the province who reside outside and who, in the last few years have decided to put our money back in the province, we are committed to walking a new path with you to restore the province. 

Masilibambe lingatshoni, Diya! 

Luxolo September is a senior Manager at the PSL. He is a consultant at FIFA, CAF and COSAFA and also an investor in agriculture in the Eastern Cape. He writes in his personal capacity. 


Article Tags


    Most Read